How to analyze a competitor's Instagram comments
Your competitor's Instagram comments are their customer feedback channel, running in public. Every 'mine arrived broken', every 'is it worth the price', every 'I switched from X and never looked back' is intelligence they cannot hide and you do not have to pay for.
Analyzing it well means reading for four specific signals rather than doom-scrolling their feed. Here is the process.
★ 4.5 on the Chrome Web Store · no card needed
The four signals in a competitor's comments
Read every competitor thread hunting for these:
- Unanswered objections: questions their brand ignores ('does it work on curly hair?') are conversations your ads can own by answering first.
- Fulfillment complaints: shipping, sizing, breakage. If they recur, reliability becomes your angle without naming anyone.
- Feature requests: 'wish it came in a bigger size' comments are a public roadmap of unmet demand.
- Switching stories: comments from people who came from another product tell you which triggers actually move buyers in your category.
Which posts to analyze
Their promoted posts and launches, where spend concentrates the audience; their most-commented organic posts, where the community talks to itself; and any post that blew up for the wrong reason. Comments under a competitor's ad are especially valuable: those are reactions from the exact audience they paid to reach, which is usually the audience you want too.
From their comments to your angles
Paste the post URL into Adlicio and the comment thread comes back clustered into ranked angles with the verbatim quotes behind each one. Run 3-4 of their posts and the recurring clusters are effectively their customers' collective review of the brand.
The move is then simple: the objection their comments raise most often becomes the promise your next ad leads with, phrased in the commenters' own words. You are not copying their marketing; you are answering their customers.
The 60-second version
- 01Scrape 3-4 of their highest-engagement posts
Launches, promoted posts, and their most-commented organic content. Paste each URL into Adlicio.
- 02Cluster and compare with your own posts
The complaints they get that you do not are your differentiators. The desires both audiences share are the category's cost of entry.
- 03Lead your ads with their unanswered objection
Answer in the first line, in the commenters' phrasing, and let your proof do the comparison implicitly.
Questions people also ask
Is it okay to analyze a competitor's comments?+
Yes. Public comments are visible to every visitor; analyzing them is standard competitive research. Adlicio only reads what is public and never interacts with the account.
Will the competitor know?+
No. Reading public comments leaves no trace on their account. Adlicio does not follow, like, or engage; it captures what a viewer sees.
What if their comments are mostly emojis?+
Common on lifestyle content, which is why promoted posts and review-style content are the better targets: paid reach pulls in strangers who ask real questions instead of fans who drop hearts.
More guides
Instagram scraperAll scrapersSee pricing
Run this play on your own Instagram page.
Paste one public URL. Adlicio returns the angle, hook, and proof to test next.